Why DRM and the DMCA sucks, part 27,541
Dear Amazon.com,
You really should get out of the business of making e-book readers. Not that there's anything wrong with the Amazon Kindle
Please stop trying to build e-book readers. Instead, let other developers build them, legally. Let a thousand e-book readers bloom.
The Kindle uses an e-book format from your subsidiary Mobipocket. I bought an e-book from Mobipocket -- once. I read it on my Nokia E62 using the Mobipocket Reader for Symbian OS. It was a crappy experience. Oh, it was nice being able to read on the subway, one teeny screen at a time. But I would have much preferred to read on the larger screen of my Nokia N810
When I was done, I wanted to refer to some passages I'd highlighted. Ideally, I'd do this on my Macintosh laptop. Unfortunately, Mobipocket doesn't have reader software for the Mac (!?!?). So I wound up using VMWare to run a copy of Windows to... just look up a passage in that e-book.
That was an awful set of hoops that you made me jump through, Amazon.
Oh the ironies of this situation. Amazon has an MP3 Download service
Conflicting priorities:
- Mobipocket (and Amazon) don't have unlimited budgets to build and support e-book reader programs for every random gadget in the universe
- The universe of pocket-size gadgets that could be e-book readers is expanding, not contracting
- I would love to step into this fray and set things straight, but I don't want to become a martyr like Dimitri Sklyarov
Amazon -- you can fix this situation. Create a web service to decrypt Mobipocket e-books. Make it accessible to registered developers who sign a terms-of-use agreement and agree to take reasonable steps within their programs to prevent unauthorized copying. Heck, you can even verify ownership of the e-book when the service is called.
You already have a thriving web services business. This should be a no-brainer for you.
If you don't want to invest in this right now -- heck, I'm willing to build this service and market it to e-book software makers, if and only if you provide me with legal indemnification so none of your publishers sue me under the DMCA.
Because... even though this could be a really nice niche business, and it would clearly benefit the e-book and publishing industries if implemented, all I need is one publisher's lawyer with his knickers in a twist to make me a fuckin' grease spot.
Until then, I'll stick to paper books.